The New Confessions – William Boyd


I read this on the Kindle – a different experience from books.  To start with it came as a blank canvas.  There is limited blurb, no comments from critics, no publishing history. Mistakenly I thought it was a recent publication, but a quick search showed that in fact it was published in 1987, and that there are Sparks notes about the book – in other words it gets studied and set in exam syllabuses.

The New Confessions tells the life story of a Scottish film director.  It’s a first person narrative – written in a formal and confessional style – which makes it rather stuffy and restrained in tone and description, perhaps a little bit boring.  The story is told chronologically, from early days, with a distant father and a child nurse in Edinburgh, through a rather unconventional public school, enlistment in WW1, the inter war years in Berlin as a film director, then Hollywood, WW2 as film journalist and of course the McCarthy witch hunts.  There is a marriage and a romance, and the ongoing attempt to film Rousseau’s The New Confessions is a recurrent theme.  There is a thread in the present which concludes each chapter, and adds little to the story – some background detail about his fame as a film producer, some insight into his current frustrations and feelings.

I suppose if I knew Rousseau’s New Confessions I’d have understood a little more about the novel – though Boyd does include some quite clear summaries and one rather long extract.  There is a lot going on here and Boyd’s perspective on some of the key moments in the twentieth century is of some interest.  However I didn’t find this as interesting as Any Human Heart, which also tells the life story of someone who lived through the twentieth century.  The narrative arc is a bit predictable, and some sections were anti-climactic: I expected more would be made of McCarthyism and the fall of the Weimar Republic.  In fact the former introduced a rather unrealistic character determined to wreak vengeance on the protagonist, and I felt this undermined the concluding chapters.

Maybe I’ve got this wrong – Goodreads has a series of very positive reviews.  Check them out:

Goodreads Reviews


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s